St James’ Park was booing by half time on Monday night, and the mood had not improved by the end of it. Newcastle lost 1-0 at home to Everton, their fourth defeat in five games across all competitions, and the man under the most scrutiny afterwards was Matthias Jaissle, appointed in August to replace Eddie Howe and barely three months into the job. Jamie Carragher, watching for Sky Sports, went further still afterwards, warning that a long season could be coming.
Thierno Barry scored the only goal in the 49th minute, tapping in at an empty net after Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall’s quick free kick and a shot from Tyrique George that squirmed under goalkeeper Lukas Hornicek. Jaissle felt there should have been a foul in the build up, pointing to an elbow from Barry on Fabian Schar, but the goal stood and Newcastle never found a way back. They did not register a shot on target until the 85th minute, when Yoane Wissa forced a save from Jordan Pickford, and Jacob Ramsey’s night ended with a second yellow card and a red in stoppage time.
It was Everton’s first away league win of the season and their first anywhere away from home since February, and it lifted David Moyes’ side up to seventh. Newcastle, by contrast, slipped to 13th, with only three wins from their opening ten league fixtures. Four points still separate them from the relegation zone, which is some comfort, but it is not the start anyone at St James’ Park imagined when Jaissle arrived promising the kind of front footed, high pressing football that made his name at Red Bull Salzburg.
A manager under more pressure than anyone expected
That is what made Carragher’s assessment afterwards so pointed. Speaking on Sky Sports, he said Newcastle’s recent performances, particularly at home, had been “flat and a little bit boring,” a description he admitted he never thought he would use about a Jaissle team. He recalled the aggressive, front foot style that was supposed to arrive with the new head coach and said he was “flummoxed” by how little of it showed up against Everton. His conclusion was blunt: “It is going to be a tough season for them. It could be a long, tough season.”
Jaissle did not try to dodge the criticism. He said his players “could not deliver” their style across the full 90 minutes, admitted the team lacked confidence, and said he understood exactly why the crowd had reacted the way it did. “If you can’t deliver when it counts, you don’t deserve to win,” he said, before adding that Newcastle were “not brave enough in possession” when it mattered. It was a notably honest assessment from a head coach who is still, in football terms, barely settled into the job.
Sky’s Andy Hinchcliffe went further on the defending itself, calling it “truly shocking” as Everton were allowed time and space in dangerous areas without the kind of pressure Jaissle’s sides are supposed to generate. For a manager whose entire appeal was built on intensity, that is the kind of criticism that cuts deepest.
The numbers behind the alarm
Beyond the mood in the stands, the underlying statistics explain why this defeat landed so heavily. Newcastle have now gone 14 straight home league games without a clean sheet, the longest such run in the club’s history. They have also suffered more Premier League home defeats in 2026 than any other side, with seven. Those are not the kind of numbers a club with Newcastle’s recent top four pedigree expects to be reading about in early November, and they help explain why patience among supporters appears to be running thinner than the calendar alone would suggest.
None of this means Jaissle’s position is in any serious danger. Three months is not a body of work on which clubs make managerial decisions, and the division around Newcastle is tight enough that 13th could look very different within a fortnight. Several Premier League clubs have shown this season that they are prepared to give new head coaches time to adapt, particularly ones brought in with a specific tactical identity in mind rather than simply short term results. But reputations built on a certain style of football come with their own pressure, and Monday’s performance was about as far from that identity as Newcastle have looked all season.
What comes next
Fulham are the visitors to St James’ Park on Saturday, arriving on the back of a win at Aston Villa that Carragher highlighted as a mark of their own momentum. It is a fixture Newcastle can realistically expect to win, and precisely the kind of game in which a response, both in results and in performance, would go a long way to settling the nerves that built up over the course of Monday night. Anything less, and the questions that followed this defeat will only grow louder.
For Jaissle personally, the test is as much about identity as it is about results. He was brought to the club to make Newcastle harder to play against and more exciting to watch. Right now, by his own admission and by the verdict of pundits who know the club well, he is managing neither. The margin for error at a club with Newcastle’s ambitions was never going to be large, and this was the week it narrowed further.
Supporters at St James’ Park have generally been patient with new arrivals in recent years, but patience tends to have limits when results and performances decline at the same time. A win over Fulham would not erase the memory of Monday night, but it would at least suggest the slide has been stopped. Another flat display, with the boos starting even earlier than they did this week, would turn a difficult week into a genuinely uncomfortable month.
If you enjoyed this, consider subscribing to It Was Always… Football for more on the stories shaping the Premier League and beyond.