Michael Carrick’s position as Manchester United manager has rarely looked shakier than it does this afternoon. A poor start to the season, a damaging Champions League defeat and a very public dressing room row have combined to put him under real scrutiny, and for the first time this season there is genuine reporting, rather than idle speculation, about who might replace him.
It has been a rough few days at Old Trafford even by this club’s recent standards. United were held 1-1 by ten man Tottenham at home on 10 October, then lost 2-0 away at Atletico Madrid in the Champions League three days later. That Atletico defeat was followed by Lisandro Martinez criticising the club’s hierarchy in a television interview, and on Thursday the fallout from that row reached a new stage when United confirmed the defender had been fined.
A season already running short of patience
Carrick guided United to third place last season, enough to earn him a permanent contract over the summer and the backing to rebuild a squad that had looked tired for years. Six games into this campaign, that investment has not translated into results. United sit 13th in the Premier League table with six points from six matches, a single win, three draws and two defeats, and a goal difference of zero. They are already twelve points behind leaders Manchester City.
None of those individual results looks catastrophic in isolation. A draw with ten man Tottenham, who themselves sit bottom of the table, is the kind of result that would normally be shrugged off rather than treated as a crisis point. But patience at Old Trafford has been thin for several years now, and a manager who was supposed to represent stability and a long term project is instead facing the same kind of scrutiny his predecessors did.
The Martinez fallout lands on Carrick’s desk
The Martinez situation has only sharpened that scrutiny. Speaking to Amazon Prime after the Atletico defeat, the Argentine defender suggested United’s hierarchy, and specifically technical director Jason Wilcox, had not properly backed Carrick in the summer transfer window. It was an unusually direct intervention from a player, and it put United’s recruitment strategy under public examination at exactly the moment results were already being questioned.
Martinez has since apologised, both to the club’s directors and to Carrick himself, for the timing and tone of his comments, even if the substance of what he said remains a live discussion internally. According to Fabrizio Romano, the club considers the fine to be the end of the formal disciplinary process for now, though Romano was careful to add that the episode will not simply be forgotten. Martinez’s contract situation, with United holding an option over an extension beyond next summer, means the row is likely to resurface whenever his future is next discussed. TEAMtalk has reported that Martinez remains available for Sunday’s trip to Leeds United and could well start, with Romano suggesting the player and the rest of the squad remain supportive of Carrick despite everything.
What the Martinez row has done, intentionally or not, is draw further attention to exactly the subject he raised: whether United’s current project, and the manager at the centre of it, is working. That question was already being asked before his comments. It is being asked considerably louder now.
The names already being discussed
This is where the story moves from a difficult week to something more serious. Over recent days, two names have repeatedly come up in connection with Carrick’s job, should United decide to make a change. The Daily Mirror has reported that Antonio Conte, out of work since leaving Napoli, has indicated to United that he would be open to taking over if Carrick were dismissed, and Italian reporting has since suggested informal contact between the two parties. Separately, several outlets have floated Brighton’s Fabian Hurzeler as an alternative, something Brighton are said to be entirely unwilling to even discuss given his new contract at the Amex.
Romano, speaking on his own channel on Thursday, was notably more cautious than some of that reporting. He said it was too early to treat either link as particularly strong, while admitting he found the Conte angle genuinely interesting given the circumstances. The key detail, according to Romano, is that Conte appears more willing than in previous windows to accept a job mid season rather than insisting on a full pre season to work with, which would represent what Romano called a significant shift from his usual stance. Romano also confirmed that United are having wider internal conversations about management options, with more than one name being discussed, even if nothing is remotely close to being finalised.
Crucially, nobody with genuine credibility is suggesting Carrick is about to be sacked immediately, or that any approach has actually been made. United have not opened talks with alternative candidates, and Carrick retains public support from the club. But the mere existence of credible, sourced reporting about alternatives, rather than social media guesswork, tells its own story about where his position currently stands.
What happens next
United travel to Leeds United on Sunday, a fixture that now carries far more significance than it would have a fortnight ago. Another underwhelming result, following the Tottenham draw and the Atletico defeat, would make it very difficult for the pressure on Carrick to ease, however much the club wants to project calm. A win, by contrast, would at least buy him some breathing space heading into a run of fixtures that will do much to define his first full season in permanent charge.
What is clear is that this is no longer purely a results story. The Martinez episode has turned a difficult league position into a wider conversation about the structure, recruitment and direction of the entire football operation, and that is a much harder thing for any manager to simply play his way out of.
If you enjoy getting under the skin of stories like this one, It Was Always… Football is worth having land in your inbox. Subscribing is free, and it takes a few seconds to join us for whatever comes next.