Newcastle United have spent the last fortnight insisting that nothing has changed. Matthias Jaissle, the head coach brought in from Al Ahli over the summer to replace Eddie Howe, says he still has the complete backing of the board, the dressing room, and anyone else who matters at St James' Park. The results, and the noise building around them, tell a slightly different story.
Newcastle sit 12th in the Premier League on 12 points from 10 matches, having won only once in their last six games in all competitions. A 2-0 win at Crystal Palace in late October was followed by a Carabao Cup exit to Everton and a home defeat to the same opponents in the league, before a 1-1 draw at Fulham on 7 November offered the faintest sign of a corner being turned. It has not been enough to stop the questions.
Whispers from the camp Jaissle insists are not there
Reports in the last week or so have suggested some players are unsettled by Jaissle's tactical instructions and unhappy with aspects of how the club has been run since Howe's abrupt exit. Mick Brown, a former Manchester United chief scout, told Football Insider it was a bad sign to be hearing rumours of discontent at all, and suggested senior figures such as captain Dan Burn and defender Sven Botman were the ones who should be stepping forward if there is genuine unhappiness to resolve. Brown stopped short of naming any player as the source of the unrest, and nobody inside the club has put their name to the claims either.
The Telegraph offered a more measured picture, reporting that while players feel hamstrung by recruitment that has left Jaissle short of the quality his predecessor had at his disposal, there is no overriding desire within the dressing room for a change of head coach. Pete O'Rourke, speaking on the Transfer Insider podcast, said the Newcastle board's support for Jaissle remains complete for now, while being honest about what ultimately decides these things. "You are judged on your results," he said.
Jaissle's own account
Jaissle has been consistent in public, repeatedly rejecting the suggestion that his players are confused by him or unhappy with his methods. He said he does not need to call special meetings to feel the backing of his squad, insisting it is obvious in the daily work on the training ground, and that he speaks regularly with sporting director Ross Wilson and chief executive David Hopkinson, both of whom he says remain fully behind him. "There's no need for meetings," he said. "You feel that support in everyday work."
He has also been open about the scale of what he inherited. Howe's exit over the summer was followed by the sales of Bruno Guimaraes and Sandro Tonali, two players who were central to Newcastle's rise under the previous regime, and Jaissle has had to build around younger replacements who have not yet shown anything like the same influence. He has talked about trying to "stay calm in the eye of the storm," while admitting there are "a lot of storms at the moment" around the club just now.
A coach with a serious record elsewhere
On paper, Jaissle's appointment made plenty of sense. The 38 year old German won back to back Austrian Bundesliga titles with Red Bull Salzburg, took that club into the Champions League knockout stages for the first time in its history, then moved to Al-Ahli in Saudi Arabia and won the AFC Champions League Elite in successive seasons, the club's first continental titles. His win rate at both clubs sat above 60%, the kind of record that gets a coach noticed well beyond where he happens to be working. Newcastle, searching for a replacement who could continue the pressing, high-intensity football that had served Howe so well, saw enough of a stylistic match to take the chance.
None of that has translated automatically to the Premier League, a competition with little patience for a coach who needs time to adapt. Jaissle began with a five-match unbeaten run that suggested the gamble might pay off quickly. The ten matches since have been considerably harder going, and it is that contrast, more than anything resembling an outright crisis on the pitch, that has turned a promising start into a managerial story.
Why the next month matters more than the last one
Newcastle go into the international break with time to regroup, but the fixtures waiting for them on the other side are unforgiving. They return away at Arsenal on 21 November, host Brighton eight days later, then travel to Manchester United on 2 December. Three matches that will tell Newcastle a great deal, not just about where they stand in the table, but about whether the board's patience with Jaissle survives contact with a run of games this demanding.
The club's own position, relayed through various reports over the past week, is that difficulties were expected when Jaissle was appointed and that there is no appetite for a change now. Whether that holds will depend a great deal on what happens in those three games. A reasonable return from Arsenal, Brighton and Manchester United would probably end the speculation, at least for now. Another slide, particularly a poor result at home to Brighton, would make Jaissle's position far harder to defend.
None of this means Jaissle is close to losing his job. Clubs often say more than they mean when results are poor, and plenty of managers have talked their way through a difficult autumn only for results to turn in their favour soon afterwards. But Newcastle's recent history suggests patience under the current ownership is not unlimited, and a club willing to move on from a popular and successful Eddie Howe only months ago is unlikely to sit on its hands for long if results do not pick up.
There is also a simpler truth in all of this, one that applies to almost every managerial saga in the Premier League. Boards back their manager right up until the moment they do not, and the only thing that reliably changes their mind is results. Jaissle has three matches to find some. What Newcastle do after that will say far more about his future than anything said about him, or by him, this week.
It Was Always... Football will be keeping an eye on how this one develops. If you enjoy coverage like this, subscribing is the best way to make sure you do not miss where it goes next.