Michael Carrick left Bruno Fernandes out of his starting eleven entirely for Sunday’s Premier League visit of Bournemouth to Old Trafford, and United lost 3-0. It was not a close call that went against them. Bournemouth were the better side from the first whistle, and United never looked like a team capable of clawing the game back, even with their captain sitting unused on the bench throughout.
The decision had been coming. Fernandes had used a television interview with Sky Italia in midweek, after United’s 4-1 Champions League defeat at Como, to suggest that managers and coaching staff should be identifying problems and making changes during matches rather than waiting for them to be aired afterwards. It read as a pointed remark about Carrick’s own approach, and on Friday, Carrick had refused to guarantee that Fernandes would keep the captaincy for the Bournemouth game. By Sunday afternoon, the answer was in: no armband, no place in the side, no introduction even when United trailed by two goals at half time.
A one sided afternoon at Old Trafford
Bournemouth’s victory was built in a devastating five minute spell either side of the 40th minute. Rayan opened the scoring in the 38th minute, finishing confidently after a foul by Ayden Heaven gave Justin Kluivert the chance to deliver a dangerous free kick into the box. United barely had time to regroup before Marcus Tavernier doubled the lead soon after, tapping in from close range after Leny Yoro lost his footing in the rain and allowed Adrien Truffert to find space to cross.
Carrick made changes at the interval, sending on Matheus Cunha and Lisandro Martinez in search of a way back into the match, but the introductions did little to change the pattern of the game. Francisco Evanilson settled any remaining doubt in the second half, rounding goalkeeper Senne Lammens after the United keeper mistimed a challenge outside his own area and finishing calmly into an empty net. There was no response of note from the home side, and by full time the Old Trafford crowd had turned audibly on their own manager, with chants aimed squarely at Carrick ringing out as United slumped to another damaging result.
Asked afterwards about leaving out his captain for the full ninety minutes, Carrick was reported to have described the call as a straightforward football decision rather than anything personal or disciplinary. Whatever the explanation, the outcome did nothing to support the reasoning behind it. United produced plenty of possession and a decent share of the shots, but precious little that troubled Bournemouth’s goal, and a midfield packed with three of the club’s summer signings never found the control Carrick had presumably been hoping it would provide.
Eight games and counting without a win
The defeat stretched United’s run without a win in all competitions to eight matches, a sequence that now spans multiple competitions and increasingly difficult circumstances. It follows directly on from the 4-1 collapse at Como that prompted Fernandes’s comments in the first place, and comes only days after Carrick’s lengthy, unprompted defence of his own methods in Friday’s press conference, when he invoked the names of Ryan Giggs, Wayne Rooney, Sir Alex Ferguson and the club’s post Munich rebuild under Sir Matt Busby and Sir Bobby Charlton while insisting there was no divide in his dressing room.
Those comparisons will look increasingly uncomfortable if results like Sunday’s continue. United remain in the lower half of the Premier League table, with seven points from their first eight league games and only a single win to show for the campaign so far, a return that leaves them closer to the relegation zone than to anywhere resembling their traditional league position. Bournemouth, by contrast, moved up to nine points with their second consecutive league victory, a timely reminder of how competitive the middle and lower reaches of the division have become. Eddie Howe’s old club, finding back to back league wins at exactly the right moment under Marco Rose, have developed an uncomfortable habit of making life difficult for Carrick’s side in particular.
A decision that raises as many questions as it answers
The wider question is not really whether Carrick was entitled to leave out his captain. Managers make selection calls of this kind all the time, and a head coach who never dared ruffle a senior player’s feathers would have a different problem altogether. The question is what the decision tells us about the relationship between Carrick and his dressing room at a moment when results have already put him under serious pressure, and whether Sunday’s performance suggests his players are still fully invested in what he is asking of them.
There was little evidence of an angry, wounded response from a team desperate to prove a point. Instead, United looked laboured and short of ideas against a side setting up specifically to catch them out, and the sense that grew across the afternoon was of a group playing for a manager many increasingly expect not to be in charge much longer. Reports in recent days have suggested the trust of the club’s ownership in Carrick is not what it was even a few weeks ago, and Sunday’s performance, allied to the manner of the defeat, will not have done anything to arrest that drift.
Carrick now faces a genuinely demanding run of fixtures, with Chelsea, Aston Villa and Liverpool all to come before the international break offers any kind of pause. Whether Fernandes returns to the side, and in what role, will be one of the first things watched closely when United’s next team news is confirmed. For now, a manager who stood his ground on a big call has watched it fail to pay off in the most visible way possible, in front of his own supporters, at the stadium where patience with him was already wearing thin.
If stories like this one keep you coming back, It Was Always… Football would love to have you as a subscriber. Hit follow or subscribe to make sure you don’t miss what comes next.