Thomas Frank has not even taken his first training session as Crystal Palace manager and already there is a decision waiting for him that has nothing to do with formations or set pieces. It concerns Ismaila Sarr, the Senegal international whose contract situation at Selhurst Park has been drifting for months, and whose future now appears to rest largely on what the club's new head coach makes of him.
Frank was confirmed as Pierre Sage's successor on 16 November, with his first match in charge coming away at Coventry City on Saturday. He takes over a side bottom of the Premier League on seven points from ten games, already fighting for survival before a ball has been kicked under him. Yet according to Football Insider, it is Frank himself who will have the final say on whether Sarr stays or goes this January, after what the outlet describes as sit down talks between the new manager and the Palace hierarchy.
A deal that has been stalling for weeks
Sarr's situation has been building since the summer, when Liverpool made an approach that ultimately came to nothing. Palace were unwilling to let him leave so late in the window, and the move fell away without a transfer materialising. Since then the 28 year old has made just one start this season, his campaign disrupted by fitness problems after a groin issue early on, a marked contrast to last term when he scored 21 goals and was the Conference League's leading marksman as Palace enjoyed a memorable European run.
Contract talks over a new deal had reportedly been described as positive in tone, even if an actual agreement was never close. What appears to have genuinely stalled things, according to TheHardTackle, is the managerial change itself. With Sage gone and Frank only just arriving, nobody at Palace has been in a position to push the conversation forward, and the uncertainty has left Sarr's camp, in the words of one report, keeping his options open.
Those options have not gone away. Liverpool are still credited with an interest, with suggestions they could return with a fresh approach once the window opens in January, while Galatasaray have also been credited with tracking him this year. Exactly which of the two Sarr himself would prefer depends on which account you believe. One report in October had him pushing for Anfield, another more recent one suggests the Turkish club has caught his attention instead. What is clear is that a player valued by Palace at well in excess of £50m is not short of admirers, even in a season where injury has limited him to barely two hours of Premier League football.
Not the only forward on Frank's desk
Sarr is not the only attacking name Frank will need to make a call on. Jean-Philippe Mateta, Palace's talisman and top scorer in recent seasons, enters the final six months of his contract in January with no extension in place. Sky Sports has reported that Palace could face a difficult choice if relegation form continues: either find a buyer in the winter window to avoid losing him for nothing in the summer, or gamble on keeping their most reliable goal threat for a survival fight that may need him more than ever.
It is an unusual position for a newly appointed head coach to inherit. Most managers walking into a relegation battle want time to work out who fits their system before making decisions on key personnel. Frank is being asked to make at least two significant calls on his most important attacking players before he has overseen a single match. Get it wrong in either direction, by selling a player who could have fired Palace to safety or by clinging to one with no long term future at the club, and the consequences could define his start at Selhurst Park every bit as much as results on the pitch.
What Frank actually has to weigh up
The case for keeping Sarr is obvious enough on paper. When fit, he is arguably the most dangerous individual talent in a squad that has struggled for goals, and a team bottom of the table cannot simply wave away a player capable of winning matches on his own. The case for cashing in is just as easy to make. He has barely featured this season, has shown before that his head can be turned by interest from elsewhere, and a club fighting relegation may prefer to bank a substantial fee now rather than risk losing more of his value if results do not improve.
Mateta's situation adds another layer. A striker entering the final months of his deal is a wasting asset in financial terms, whatever he offers on the pitch, and Palace's position in the table only sharpens that dilemma. Keep him and risk losing him for nothing later, or sell him now and weaken the side just as a new manager needs every attacking option available.
None of this will be settled quickly, and nothing here amounts to confirmation that either player is actually leaving in January. What does seem settled is that Frank, barely in the building, already has more on his plate than simply preparing a team for Coventry. How he handles it may say as much about his judgement as anything that happens on the touchline this weekend.
If you enjoy stories like this, consider subscribing to It Was Always... Football for more on the games, deals and decisions shaping the season.


