Nine games into the season, and the team sitting third in the Premier League table is not one of the usual names fighting at the top. It is Brighton and Hove Albion, five points behind leaders Arsenal, playing some of the most composed, defensively disciplined football in the country under a head coach who was the youngest man ever to take charge of a Premier League club when he arrived.
Fabian Hurzeler was 31 when Brighton appointed him from St Pauli in the summer of 2024, a gamble that looked bold even by the club's own unconventional standards. Eighteen months on, with a new long term contract signed in May that runs through to 2029, he has Brighton playing a version of the football that first brought Graham Potter and then Roberto De Zerbi so much admiration, only now backed by genuinely elite defensive numbers to go with it.
The best defence in the Premier League
Brighton have conceded just seven goals in nine league matches, the lowest total in the division, while also scoring the most of any side in the competition. It is a combination few would have predicted from a club that sold Moises Caicedo for a club record fee and has spent recent seasons as one of English football's most reliable exporters of talent rather than a team assembled to compete at the very top.
The results back up the numbers. Brighton have already beaten three of last season's top five finishers this term, defeating Arsenal, Aston Villa and, most strikingly, Manchester City 1-0 at the Etihad Stadium on 31 October, their first ever win there. They also knocked Manchester United out of the Carabao Cup. Compare that to the equivalent stage of De Zerbi's title chasing 2023-24 campaign, when Brighton had five wins, one draw and three defeats after nine games, conceding 18 goals along the way. Hurzeler's side have six wins, one draw and two defeats, and have conceded 11 fewer.
Why nobody is quite calling it a title challenge yet
Bookmakers have Brighton as third favourites for the title at 14 to 1, well behind Arsenal and Manchester City, and most inside the game remain cautious about reading too much into early season form. Brighton's history offers its own warning. A seven point lead over Middlesbrough in the 2016-17 Championship evaporated after a string of late season errors, and De Zerbi's own promising start two seasons ago eventually ran into a congested fixture list that wore the squad down by spring.
That risk has not gone away. Brighton are also competing in the Conference League this season, and a run through Europe alongside the Carabao Cup, FA Cup and Premier League will eventually mean games coming thick and fast through December and January. One Sky Sports pundit has already flagged the physical cost of Hurzeler's demanding pressing style over a long season, pointing out that sustaining that intensity across four competitions is a very different test to maintaining it in the league alone. There is also the unresolved question of Manchester City's financial rules case hanging over the whole division. City still face charges from a Premier League commission, with an appeal ongoing, and nobody at Brighton will be looking that far ahead while that remains unsettled. Brighton's own record against lower placed sides has not always been reliable either, and testing away trips to supposedly weaker opposition later in the season will say a great deal about whether this really is sustainable.
What is actually driving the form
For all the caveats, what stands out about this Brighton side is that it is not relying on one outstanding individual or a single tactical trick. Lewis Dunk anchors a defence that has rediscovered its old solidity, and the pressing triggers that made Brighton so admired under De Zerbi have returned with sharper edges under Hurzeler's coaching. Kaoru Mitoma, who turned down interest from Arsenal, Bayern Munich and Barcelona to sign a new contract, remains the team's most direct source of chance creation out wide, while the club record signing of 18 year old Greek forward Charalampos Kostoulas from Olympiacos last summer, a deal worth around £30 million, shows Brighton are now willing to spend big on potential rather than simply harvest and sell it. Hurzeler called him "outstanding" on arrival, and the strength in depth that signing and others have added means injuries to key players have not derailed results the way they once might have.
Hurzeler himself has been consistent in his messaging throughout. He has repeatedly made the point that a club can fight for Europe, or more, while operating with one of the smaller budgets among the Premier League's upper reaches, and that sticking together as a group matters more than any individual outlay. It is a message that has started to look like more than just a coach managing expectations.
Brighton's next test comes at the Amex on Saturday against Brentford, themselves enjoying a strong season in sixth place, in a match that will do plenty to establish whether this current run is a genuine sign of what is to come or simply an excellent purple patch. Either way, a club with Brighton's track record for selling its best players and still competing deserves credit for building something that, nine games in, looks like a great deal more than an early season flash in the pan.
If stories like this are the ones you want delivered twice a day, subscribe to It Was Always... Football and never miss the next one.