Michael Carrick will have taken some encouragement from Elland Road on Sunday. His side were better organised, harder to break down, and came away with a point after Bryan Mbeumo’s opener was cancelled out by a Dominic Calvert-Lewin header from a corner. But a draw is still a draw, and it leaves United winless in six matches across all competitions, sitting 13th in the Premier League with seven points from seven games and just a single win to their name.
Neville, never short of an opinion where his old club are concerned, gave Carrick credit for the shape of the performance. He called the result a “stepping stone” and pointed to clear signs of progress: a United side that was more compact, harder to play through, and showing the outline of a plan rather than simply hoping for the best. He even floated a possible blueprint for games like this one, with Matheus Cunha and Marcus Rashford held back to be introduced from the bench as the match opened up.
And yet the warning that followed mattered more than the compliment that preceded it. Neville was blunt about what thirteenth place means if it is still the picture in January. Carrick, he said, “has a problem” if United are still sat there when the new year arrives. It is too early for panic after seven games, Neville added, but the clock is now visibly running, and everybody at Old Trafford knows it.
Why January Is the Number That Matters
There is nothing arbitrary about the timeframe Neville has chosen. January is when a struggling Premier League season either gets fixed or gets away from a club for good. It is the point by which a false start can no longer be blamed on pre season fitness or unfamiliar systems. It is also when boardrooms start to look seriously at the table and ask whether the current project still has a route back to where it needs to be.
For United, that route is specific. Neville has made clear he regards anything outside the top five as a genuine failure this season, not because of pride or tradition, but because of money. Missing out on Champions League qualification again would mean another year in the Europa League and another year without the broadcast revenue, prize money and prestige that comes with Europe’s top competition. United currently sit five points off fifth place having played seven games, a gap that is recoverable in October but considerably harder to close by the spring if it widens further over the coming weeks.
This is the context that turns a mid table draw into a story with real stakes. Carrick was not appointed to keep United ticking over in the bottom half. He was appointed, at least in part, on the promise of exactly the kind of identity Neville saw flickers of against Leeds: organised, difficult to beat, building towards something. The problem is that flickers of promise and points on the board are two very different currencies, and only one of them keeps a manager in his job.
The Players Carrying the Weight of the Plan
Some of the detail in Neville’s analysis was more encouraging. Carlos Baleba, signed from Brighton for a reported £70 million in the summer, has shown enough already to suggest United got the profile of player right even if the results have not yet followed. Neville was keen to stress that managing Baleba’s fitness carefully matters more than chasing instant returns from him, and even suggested resting him for Wednesday’s Champions League trip to Como might be the sensible call given the weight he is already carrying in midfield.
The pairing of Baleba with Andrey Santos was another thread Neville picked up on, questioning whether keeping that partnership settled, rather than constantly shuffling the midfield, might be the quickest way to make United harder to play against. It was a pointed observation, because that has been precisely the criticism levelled at United for much of this season: a team that is too easy to find space against, too easy to play through, and too often undone by moments it should be controlling.
There were some green shoots elsewhere in the division to put United’s situation in perspective. Neville noted that Brighton, Liverpool and Aston Villa all looked to be improving sides this autumn, a reminder that the teams United are chasing are not standing still either. Fifth place is not a fixed target that will simply wait for United to arrive at it.
A Fixture List That Will Answer the Question Itself
United do not have long to find out whether Sunday’s performance was the platform Neville described or a brief upturn in a difficult season. Wednesday brings a Champions League trip to Como, followed by Bournemouth at Old Trafford on the twenty fifth of October and a trip to Chelsea six days after that. A home Champions League tie against Roma and a visit from Aston Villa follow in early November, before United travel to Liverpool in late November in what already looks like a defining fixture either way.
None of those games are must win in isolation. Taken together, though, they form exactly the stretch by which Neville’s January marker will be judged. A side showing genuine improvement should be picking up results against Bournemouth and in the Europa League style run that follows. A side still searching for answers will arrive at the turn of the year with Neville’s warning ringing true, and with considerably less patience left in the stands than there is right now.
Carrick has earned himself some credit after Elland Road. Whether that credit still exists by the time January comes around is, by his own former teammate’s estimation, entirely in his own hands.
If you enjoyed this, consider subscribing to It Was Always… Football for more on the stories shaping the season.